'Herman Mashaba dances to EFF tune'

Herman Mashaba the first DA mayor in Johannesburg has been accused of being a puppet of the EFF, who are seen as kingmakers in the Joburg council.
Herman Mashaba the first DA mayor in Johannesburg has been accused of being a puppet of the EFF, who are seen as kingmakers in the Joburg council.
Image: Moeletsi Mabe

The EFF publicly brags about Johannesburg mayor Herman Mashaba being their own even though he is in the top job via the DA ticket.

This bragging has not gone down well with Mashaba's fellow DA councillors and opposition parties, who accuse him of dancing to every tune of the red brigade.

They cite the suspension of health and social development MMC Mpho Phalatse after she declared that the metro was a friend of Israel earlier this month as a clear indication that the EFF, the metro's election kingmaker, was calling the shots.

Before Mashaba suspended Phalatse the EFF had said it would not support the city's R59-billion budget if she was not iced or fired.

DA councillors and opposition parties were also infuriated by Mashaba's decision to please the EFF by rejecting the appointment of Heather Trumble as the building control officer.

The EFF rejected the appointment of Trumble on the basis that she is a white woman. The EFF demand led to the metro appointing Celiwe Mtebula as the building control officer.

The EFF also pushed for a moratorium on removing people illegally invading land in the metro.

Yesterday DA councillor Annette Deppe squashed claims that the EFF was controlling Mashaba.

"EFF are our partners. It was an agreement we took in 2016. They vote with us case by case. That is going to be like that. We work very well with them," Deppe said.

But another DA councillor who asked for anonymity said: "They (EFF) have got us by the balls, when they want to squeeze, they squeeze."

ANC Johannesburg region spokesman Jolidee Matongo said the DA was not in charge of the metro.

"As the ANC we believe that the EFF is running the city of Johannesburg. It is demonstrated by a number of things: The executive would bring reports to council when the EFF has a problem with those reports and the executive would withdraw the reports.

Health MMC Mpho Phalatse
Health MMC Mpho Phalatse

"We believe that after withdrawing the reports they then go and consult the EFF and try and see what the EFF wants to see from those particular reports," Matongo said.

Patriotic Alliance councillor Lloyd Philips said racist decisions were being taken to please the EFF.

"It appears smaller political parties are being undermined and disregarded even when decisions that are blatantly racist are taken just because of the EFF veto over the Mashaba administration," he said.

"During the second attempt to pass the city's budget, the Patriotic Alliance, along with the EFF, gave an input into possible amendments to the budget but only the EFF input was acknowledged and approved while the Patriotic Alliance input was blatantly disregarded.

Mashaba's spokesman, Luyanda Mfeka, said there were extensive engagements with members of the DA caucus and the EFF on all decisions.

"In all of these engagements mayor Mashaba has sought and received the support of all parties involved in governing of Johannesburg.

"For the first time in the history of Johannesburg a multi-party government is operating in a consultative manner without the arrogance that comes with a majority governing party. This is precisely what the residents of our city wanted following years of an arrogant, out-of-touch ANC majority government," he said.

EFF caucus leader Musa Novela described as "madness" claims that the party was controlling Mashaba.

"We come to the council and make substantive arguments and proposals. It is not our problem that the EFF is the active opposition party. Are we controlling Mashaba when we propose that tariffs should be reduced? We have got our own constituency, which is the poor people, our constituency is not the DA. We will continue to make counter proposals."

Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments? Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.