×

We've got news for you.

Register on SowetanLIVE at no cost to receive newsletters, read exclusive articles & more.
Register now

Court finds Minister Oliphant to be ‘irrational and unfair’

April 9, 2014. Mildred Oliphant , Minister of Labour at Employment Equity Indaba. Pic: Russell Roberts. © Business Day.
April 9, 2014. Mildred Oliphant , Minister of Labour at Employment Equity Indaba. Pic: Russell Roberts. © Business Day.

The Democratic Alliance and labour federations have vowed to write to the President and the International Labour Organisation over Labour Minister Mildred Oliphant’s treatment of chemical workers union Ceppwawu.

Last week‚ acting labour court Judge Anton Myburgh ruled that labour registrar Johan Crouse be reinstated‚ finding that Oliphant had been “unreasonable‚ alternatively irrational and procedurally unfair” in her decision to remove him from his post earlier this year.

DA labour spokesman Ian Ollis and labour federations Fedusa and Nactu said the treatment of Crouse‚ who had been acting to place the ailing Cosatu affiliated Ceppwawu under administration‚ smacked of political cronyism.

The Department of Labour will be appealing the judgment.

Oliphant had written to Crouse shortly after he had instituted court action in June‚ demanding to know why she had not been briefed and that the matter be suspended.

After Crouse failed to do so‚ she revoked his appointment as registrar and ordered that state resources not be used to fund the court action.

The court matter detailed the concerns about the future of the union‚ which in addition to its lack of financial accounting since 2010‚ had seen legal battles between leadership‚ and had failed to hold an AGM.

In his submissions Crouse wrote that he believed “there might be serious mismanagement of its finances under way to the prejudice of its members”.

Myburgh found that this‚ coupled with a letter from Ceppwawu Investments’ attorneys‚ was cause for concern.

“If this letter is anything to go by‚ Mr Crouse’s concerns about serious financial mismanagement are well founded.”

Crouse also argued that in his twenty years in the role of registrar‚ he had never once been asked to brief the minister on such matters. He submitted that over the past five years‚ he had cancelled the registrations of 81 unions without briefing senior department management.

“It is not clear what makes the Ceppwawu matter different from the other cases that have been dealt with‚” Crouse states.

And while the judgment did not make any findings on political interference‚ Fedusa general secretary Dennis George said Ceppwawu appeared to be getting preferential treatment because of its links to Cosatu and the ruling party.

“If a Fedusa union is in trouble‚ they want to close our unions down‚ but here there is some correlation between the relationships...”

Both Fedusa and Nactu have previously written to Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa regarding the issue but both unions on Friday said they had not had responses.

George said he hoped for an opportunity to address the issue of the “toxic leadership” in labour at the ANC congress.

“I have been invited to attend‚ and if I get the opportunity‚ I am going to raise this issue with the President or the Deputy President‚” he said.

Nactu President Joseph Maqhekeni said they “condemned” the labour department’s move to appeal the judgment and the request for 90 days in which to prepare the financials.

“That union should have been under administration long‚ long ago‚” he said.

Nactu was now considering approaching the regional offices of the International Labour Organisation to take up the matter‚ he said.

Ollis said who would write to President Jacob Zuma calling for Oliphant’s head.

 “It is quite clear that the Minister is merely trying to protect the General-Secretary of Ceppwawu because he is aligned to the current Cosatu and ANC leadership‚ by preventing the Ceppwawu matter being heard in a court of law. This is gross political interference.”

Spokesman for the minister‚ Sithembele Tshwete said that the department had submitted an appeal but could not comment further on the matter.

 

 

Would you like to comment on this article?
Register (it's quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.