Lawyers for murder accused trio in Phoenix unrest poke holes in policeman's evidence

Siblings Dylan and Ned Govender with Jeetendra Jaikissoon face murder charges after the death of 19-year-old Mondli Majola in Phoenix during unrest in July.
Siblings Dylan and Ned Govender with Jeetendra Jaikissoon face murder charges after the death of 19-year-old Mondli Majola in Phoenix during unrest in July.
Image: Mfundo Mkhize

The arrests of three men in connection with the death of Mondli Majola in Phoenix during the height of July unrest smacks of buckling to pressure from the national police minister.

That was the assertion by the defence lawyer, Carl van der Merwe, for siblings Dylan and Ned Govender who together with a third man, Jeetendra Jaikissoon, face murder charges in connection with the death of 19-year-old Mondli Majola from Amaoti. Dylan faces an additional attempted murder charge.

On Wednesday, Van der Merwe cross-examined Phoenix unrest task team member Sgt Siphosenkosi Shezi about video evidence related to Majola’s death.

Shezi previously told Verulam magistrate Irfan Khalil that police had secured video evidence which placed the accused at the scene of the crime and provided a sequence of events that led to Majola’s death. He claimed that a mob of men, including the accused, had attacked Majola and others, who escaped.

However, Van der Merwe argued that in the aftermath of the unrest which claimed 36 lives and which saw the Phoenix suburb transform into a war zone, there seemed to be mounting pressure from police minister Bheki Cele for police to arrest suspects. This, he said, resulted in a biased police investigation.

He also questioned Shezi's observation when in previous evidence he estimated that there were “six or seven” occupants, including the accused, who arrived in the bakkie on the day in question.

However, it emerged that there were only three people in the vehicle, according to video footage played in court.

“You are trying to embroider information to create an impression that there was a mob of people,” he told Shezi, before adding that the policeman’s observation skills could not be trusted.

Shezi did not disagree with the attorney’s statement with regard to the number but said the violence was “out of hand”.

The bail application continues on Friday.

TimesLIVE


Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments? Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.