The government employs more than a fifth of formal sector workers in South Africa and pays its employees an average 34% more than the private sector does.
This is what happens when you allow COSATU to get too powerful.
South Africa is uncompetitive, without our gold and platinum & the respective overvalued market prices of these commodities, South Africa is merely another Greece.
We dont have a competitive workforce, we dont have a industry that has comparative advantage or absolute advantage to any of our competitors, and our political grip over Africa is also on the decline as the rise of Nigeria, and in the long run, Angola & Egypt will by a long shot overtake us as important representatives of this continent.
Jeez. 34% more than the private sector? What absolute bull. People doing similar work to mine in private sector companies earn a great deal more than I do. Report Abuse
May 8, 2012
The-Rothschilds
South Africa would of been a much more wealthy nation today had we undertaken a productive route over a welfare route.
Unemployment is the biggest threat facing our Country Report Abuse
May 8, 2012
KokoMma
I disagree. Unemployment is a chronic desease in this country. Wish it can permanently be healed Report Abuse
May 8, 2012
The-Rothschilds
KokoMma
I disagree. Unemployment is a chronic desease in this country. Wish it can permanently be healed
================================================================================
And the ruling party undertook a short-run temporary solution to reducing unemployment.......................by over inflating our public sector (instead of investing in the private sector to create more sustainable jobs that dont put pressure on the fiscal budget) and welfare grants.................by making people become reliant on unproductive subsidies (thats puts immense pressure on our fiscal budget), Only the sick, physically disadvantaged and elderly, should be allowed to live on welfare grants.
The problem lies in the fact that the ANC failed to facilitate a private sector that could grow fast enough to dent the unemployment rate fast enough.
Blame it on the new government departments which were introduced which am not sure what their role is and the wages you are talking about are on high level (Head of Departments, MEC's, Ministers, Municipal Managers, MP's etc - you name them Report Abuse
May 8, 2012
cornelius
Of course the lik.es of " D.ie L.em " Nzima.nde and " Viva" Vavi will be dismi.ssive of the findings in the report, coming from an " an.ti revolu.tionia.ry w.hite cap.talist pi.g econo.mist." and we will strug.gle on and down from the one unemplo.yment record to the next. Report Abuse
May 8, 2012
rasefatee
Then msholosi retrench those who don’t go to work on Mondays due to babalas,on pay days and those whose files are infested with sick notes this is their time to go rest in peace at home Report Abuse
May 8, 2012
TheDictator
@RobinH
Jeez. 34% more than the private sector? What absolute bull. People doing similar work to mine in private sector companies earn a great deal more than I do
...............................................................................
I agree with you there comrade Robin.Unless if I don't understand the models that they ran to conduct the study.I'm in public sector and folks here are paid next to nothing. Report Abuse
May 8, 2012
Mabenito
Bull sh*t...
I don't know how they figured that out, but seriously, you are talking twak bosso..! Report Abuse
May 8, 2012
Mogwapatholo
TheDictator
@RobinH
Jeez. 34% more than the private sector? What absolute bull. People doing similar work to mine in private sector companies earn a great deal more than I do
...............................................................................
I agree with you there comrade Robin.Unless if I don't understand the models that they ran to conduct the study.I'm in public sector and folks here are paid next to nothing.
***********************************************************************************
"South Africa's formal sector often overpays those with relatively few skills, while those with skills are often underpaid in relative terms, the 2012 South African Employment Report shows". i think you fall within the Skilled labour and publuc sector often get paid some of their salary in benefits which you do not get as cash. check your employer's contribution to your pension fund you'll see what i'm talking about. Report Abuse
Mogwapatholo: Thanks for your comment. I do fall within the "skilled labour" sector. But I am quite clear about my view that I am underpaid compare4d to equals in the private sector, and I DOP take the "benefits" you mention into account. I must point out that many of the benefits I think you refer to do not always apply. I have no medical aid. I get a pathetic housing allowance. My pension has just been raided by the eToll contribution. I CAN DO SUMS!
RobinH
Jeez. 34% more than the private sector? What absolute bull. People doing similar work to mine in private sector companies earn a great deal more than I do.
Hi Robin, where do you work for government if I may ask? Report Abuse
May 9, 2012
PleaseGetReal
Once again we would like to thank the anc supporters for your help sending this country to turmoil, Report Abuse
May 9, 2012
RobinH
Please get real. I work in the Health sector. I would prefer not to give more detail. Report Abuse
May 9, 2012
PleaseGetReal
RobinH
Please get real. I work in the Health sector. I would prefer not to give more detail.
I would really like to know how true this article is, if there is any truth to it they would have obviously used an average, the problem is that it could be 100% true when one look at the bloated salaries of cadre's that is put into the system. I think you may be one of the unlucky honest people who got his job and salary on the honest ways. Report Abuse
May 9, 2012
RobinH
Personally I don't think much decent research was done. But I do speak under correction. The jump between salary levels from level 10 upward is very big. High ranks earn a shitload, and of course that is exactly where incompetent cadre deployment is taking place, even in the DA controlled W Cape where I am. Report Abuse
May 9, 2012
MommaC
So if you are unskilled then you get a higher salary working for government but if you are skilled then you get a lower salary if you work for government. That explains much. Report Abuse
I have been been to both Angola and Egypt very recently and I assure you they wil not come close ro SA any time soon. Angola is going the dictaror route with 1% of the top stealong all the oil and diamond money. Egypt, well what can I say, their religious stance will keep them back for many years.
But I agree thank Cosatu and the unions for SA not being competative.
The figures are accurate but it is also easy to see why people recacts this way. They have no idea how our salary bills effect costings. And what salaries for unskilled labour is suppose to be. Report Abuse
May 9, 2012
Traveljunie
eish, damn buttons on cell is so small it's difficult type without mistakes Report Abuse
May 9, 2012
The-Rothschilds
Traveljunie
Regarding Egypt and Angola..........i did say in the LONG RUN..........purely because of population growth and geo political influence and ofcourse, oil! Report Abuse
If you feel a comment on the site does not meet our general comments guidelines (see below), you can report the comment.
Comments guidelines:
Comments should be relevant to the article or the thread of conversation
Comments should not make personal attacks
Comments should not use vulgar, discriminatory, obscene or abusive language
Once reported, we will review the complaint you have made and the reason for it.
We will then take any action we believe appropriate and is within our rights. Please refer to the Terms and Conditions which are agreed to when registering on Sowetan LIVE.
Comments
The-Rothschilds
This is what happens when you allow COSATU to get too powerful.South Africa is uncompetitive, without our gold and platinum & the respective overvalued market prices of these commodities, South Africa is merely another Greece.
We dont have a competitive workforce, we dont have a industry that has comparative advantage or absolute advantage to any of our competitors, and our political grip over Africa is also on the decline as the rise of Nigeria, and in the long run, Angola & Egypt will by a long shot overtake us as important representatives of this continent.
Report Abuse
RobinH
Jeez. 34% more than the private sector? What absolute bull. People doing similar work to mine in private sector companies earn a great deal more than I do.Report Abuse
The-Rothschilds
South Africa would of been a much more wealthy nation today had we undertaken a productive route over a welfare route.But we all know that a ANC vote = welfare
Need i explain anymore?
Report Abuse
SeshegoGuY
Unemployment is the biggest threat facing our CountryReport Abuse
KokoMma
I disagree. Unemployment is a chronic desease in this country. Wish it can permanently be healedReport Abuse
The-Rothschilds
KokoMmaI disagree. Unemployment is a chronic desease in this country. Wish it can permanently be healed
================================================================================
And the ruling party undertook a short-run temporary solution to reducing unemployment.......................by over inflating our public sector (instead of investing in the private sector to create more sustainable jobs that dont put pressure on the fiscal budget) and welfare grants.................by making people become reliant on unproductive subsidies (thats puts immense pressure on our fiscal budget), Only the sick, physically disadvantaged and elderly, should be allowed to live on welfare grants.
The problem lies in the fact that the ANC failed to facilitate a private sector that could grow fast enough to dent the unemployment rate fast enough.
Report Abuse
TKay
Blame it on the new government departments which were introduced which am not sure what their role is and the wages you are talking about are on high level (Head of Departments, MEC's, Ministers, Municipal Managers, MP's etc - you name themReport Abuse
cornelius
Of course the lik.es of " D.ie L.em " Nzima.nde and " Viva" Vavi will be dismi.ssive of the findings in the report, coming from an " an.ti revolu.tionia.ry w.hite cap.talist pi.g econo.mist." and we will strug.gle on and down from the one unemplo.yment record to the next.Report Abuse
rasefatee
Then msholosi retrench those who don’t go to work on Mondays due to babalas,on pay days and those whose files are infested with sick notes this is their time to go rest in peace at homeReport Abuse
TheDictator
@RobinHJeez. 34% more than the private sector? What absolute bull. People doing similar work to mine in private sector companies earn a great deal more than I do
...............................................................................
I agree with you there comrade Robin.Unless if I don't understand the models that they ran to conduct the study.I'm in public sector and folks here are paid next to nothing.
Report Abuse
Mabenito
Bull sh*t...I don't know how they figured that out, but seriously, you are talking twak bosso..!
Report Abuse
Mogwapatholo
TheDictator@RobinH
Jeez. 34% more than the private sector? What absolute bull. People doing similar work to mine in private sector companies earn a great deal more than I do
...............................................................................
I agree with you there comrade Robin.Unless if I don't understand the models that they ran to conduct the study.I'm in public sector and folks here are paid next to nothing.
***********************************************************************************
"South Africa's formal sector often overpays those with relatively few skills, while those with skills are often underpaid in relative terms, the 2012 South African Employment Report shows". i think you fall within the Skilled labour and publuc sector often get paid some of their salary in benefits which you do not get as cash. check your employer's contribution to your pension fund you'll see what i'm talking about.
Report Abuse
munhu
mReport Abuse
RobinH
Mogwapatholo: Thanks for your comment. I do fall within the "skilled labour" sector. But I am quite clear about my view that I am underpaid compare4d to equals in the private sector, and I DOP take the "benefits" you mention into account. I must point out that many of the benefits I think you refer to do not always apply. I have no medical aid. I get a pathetic housing allowance. My pension has just been raided by the eToll contribution. I CAN DO SUMS!Report Abuse
PleaseGetReal
RobinHJeez. 34% more than the private sector? What absolute bull. People doing similar work to mine in private sector companies earn a great deal more than I do.
Hi Robin, where do you work for government if I may ask?
Report Abuse
PleaseGetReal
Once again we would like to thank the anc supporters for your help sending this country to turmoil,Report Abuse
RobinH
Please get real. I work in the Health sector. I would prefer not to give more detail.Report Abuse
PleaseGetReal
RobinHPlease get real. I work in the Health sector. I would prefer not to give more detail.
I would really like to know how true this article is, if there is any truth to it they would have obviously used an average, the problem is that it could be 100% true when one look at the bloated salaries of cadre's that is put into the system. I think you may be one of the unlucky honest people who got his job and salary on the honest ways.
Report Abuse
RobinH
Personally I don't think much decent research was done. But I do speak under correction. The jump between salary levels from level 10 upward is very big. High ranks earn a shitload, and of course that is exactly where incompetent cadre deployment is taking place, even in the DA controlled W Cape where I am.Report Abuse
MommaC
So if you are unskilled then you get a higher salary working for government but if you are skilled then you get a lower salary if you work for government. That explains much.Report Abuse
RobinH
Morning Momma..... Everyone.Report Abuse
Traveljunie
@ The-Rothschilds,I have been been to both Angola and Egypt very recently and I assure you they wil not come close ro SA any time soon. Angola is going the dictaror route with 1% of the top stealong all the oil and diamond money. Egypt, well what can I say, their religious stance will keep them back for many years.
But I agree thank Cosatu and the unions for SA not being competative.
The figures are accurate but it is also easy to see why people recacts this way. They have no idea how our salary bills effect costings. And what salaries for unskilled labour is suppose to be.
Report Abuse
Traveljunie
eish, damn buttons on cell is so small it's difficult type without mistakesReport Abuse
The-Rothschilds
TraveljunieRegarding Egypt and Angola..........i did say in the LONG RUN..........purely because of population growth and geo political influence and ofcourse, oil!
Report Abuse
Read all 24 comments