• Tweet

MASS ACTION: Cosatu members march through the streets of Pretoria in protest against the e-tolling system. PHOTO: BAFANA MAHLANGU

RELATED ARTICLES

• More court action for Sanral
• Court says opposition had 4 years to oppose tolls

On Saturday, Judge Bill Prinsloo granted the Urban Tolling Alliance (Outa) an interdict halting the implementation of Gauteng's much-contested e-tolling system.

Granting the interdict Judge Prinsloo said : "People are held captive by the toll roads.

"I make the following order... the first respondent [SA National Roads Agency] is interdicted and restrained from levying and collecting tolls." The public gallery applauded.

Now, after being postponed five times, the e-toll system will have to wait for the outcome of a court review.

Given the support that the controversial project had received from the government - both the Treasury and the Ministry of Transport had expressed their support for the project - there was an expectation that the court may relent to "political pressure" anddismiss Outa's application.

By granting the interdict Judge Prinsloo has once more asserted the independence of the judiciary.

By arguing that the people were going to be held captive by the e-tolls, Judge Prinsloo has confirmed one of the basic tenets of democracy - that the government should govern in the interest of the people.

In so doing, the judge has nullified the argument by the Treasury that halting the implementation of the e-tolls would impact on the government's ability to attract foreign investment.

In supporting the implementation of the e-tolls, the Treasury argued that halting the project would create an impression that South Africa was unstable for foreign investment.

By granting the interdict Judge Prinsloo has actually confirmed that the inverse applies - that is, if the tolls were implemented regardless of the public opposition to the project, this would create the kind of instability that is averse to any foreign investment.

What the decision also says is that the government should go back to the drawing board and, together with the broader South African community, explore alternative means of funding the improvement of our public roads in a manner acceptable to all.

The reality is that our country needs to maintain its freeways and public roads, but this cannot be done in a top-down manner that excludes the very people who are supposed to benefit from such efforts.

Comments

• Sign in or sign up to comment

Wed Jun 19 19:13:20 SAST 2013 ::

Apr 30, 2012

Mphokolodi02

Nice i like i like ,this E-toll nonsense should stop ,im paying enough to tax to Anc let them take it from ther ,i wont ever more than i am paying ,kanting whos working in the early hours to go work her ass off me,so if they need money they should go work 2 stop manipulating us,,,,,,,documents se gatttt
Report Abuse

Apr 30, 2012

maneater

has anybody seen the honorable Jimmy Manyi anywhere? i need to hear him talk !!!!!!i need to hear him talk !!!!!!!!
Report Abuse

Apr 30, 2012

Bonsao

Thank you, Where is IZINYOKA?
Report Abuse

May 2, 2012

truthhurt

28 April should be a Holiday, its the day the people said no to Highway robbery, injustice, e-theft and oppression in a democratic country. Thank God For Our Constitution, We Were F*#cked Hey!
Report Abuse

Read all 4 comments